Monday, August 10, 2015

Setting the Scene
This is what I know about my mother, June, that she has related to me.  Mom was born in 1924 to a 2nd generation Swedish-American father, and a Swedish immigrant mother.  She had two older brothers, and there was a fairly large gap between the younger brother and her—maybe seven or eight years. Her mother emigrated from Sweden when she was only 17 years old, the first in her family to do so.  Of five children, four of them would eventually leave Sweden.  She had indentured herself for seven years to a family to work as a house maid in Chicago.  She met my grandfather during that time, but she couldn’t marry until her indenture was completed.  Getting married at age 24 back in 1914 was considered old. Their marriage certificate describes her as “the spinster, Lydia Thor”!  My grandfather was even older, in his 30s when they married.  A few years into the marriage, they had a baby girl whom they named Lily, but she died before she turned a month old.   My mother laments the death of her older sister, so I think Lily must not have been far from everyone’s thoughts in that family.  They soon afterward had two boys born within a couple of years of each other.  Then a space of several years, then my mother.  She says that her father, whom she endearingly called “Popsy-boy” was 50 when she was born, and her mother was in her late 30's. My mom was 5 years old when the stock market crashed, and the family was plunged with every other American family into the Great Depression.  My grandparents already had their house paid for, so thankfully they didn’t lose it, but my grandfather lost his printing business.  At some point he found work as a custodian at a grade school, but it sounds like their lives were seriously impacted regardless.  Her mother seems to loom large as a very practical, even harsh woman during this time.  My mom tells stories about my grandmother not allowing a Christmas tree because they were too poor to power the lights for it; that she would not buy my mother white stockings to wear to school for picture day. The photo itself confirms the story—there’s my forlorn 8 year-old mother standing in the front row with her stretched out brown stockings, one up to her knee, the other sagging to her ankle, flanked by all the other girls with nice white stockings and starched pinafores. My mom tells a story about how her dad once brought home a pretty dress that he had bought for her, and her mother lit into him for spending money so extravagantly. She made him take it back. Once, only once, she told me about the day she heard her mother say to her father, “We should never have had that kid.” That must have cut like a knife, and I am certain that, along with a thousand other ways a person may devalue a child’s self-worth, was the catalyst for my mother’s lifelong emotional problems.  Perhaps she said it out of despair for their financial state, and for the emotional impact and stress that must have had on the family. I wonder, too, how much my grandmother suffered from her own childhood problems.  I know teenagers are eager to be on their own, but moving thousands of miles away from home, to another country and culture, and without much prospect for future contact other than through the mail?  I can’t even begin to imagine her reasons. There are other stories that shine a brighter light on my grandmother.  My mom tells how she used to read and mark her Swedish Bible. She didn’t attend church (my mom says it was because she said she didn’t feel she fit in), but she supplied bakery for one church’s soup kitchen.  I’m pretty sure she was paid for that endeavor, but still, she baked all day on Saturday to provide the rolls for Sunday’s lunch. My uncle’s wife told me “Lydia was very kind. She used to set out milk and bread for the bums who frequented the alley behind their house. When your uncle and I were first married, we were going to have to take our clothes to a laundromat. She insisted that we bring it to her instead, and she washed and hung our clothes to dry.”  My mother has said that it was her mother’s dream to move to Coeur d’Alene Idaho where my grandfather’s brother had moved and open a bakery/coffee house.  They planned to move when my mom finished high school, but unfortunately those plans were dashed when my grandmother died of cancer when my mom was 14 years old. That, too, was traumatic. My mom has expressed regret that she never got to know her mother as an adult, anger that her mother didn’t seek treatment, and at the end would not allow my mother to visit her, and great sadness and loneliness after her death. 

I’m certain my mother’s childhood was difficult and harsh.  It’s unfortunate that she wasn’t able to get the emotional help she needed.  I believe she was left to cope on her own. For her, coping meant creating another June. A June that people loved and wanted, took care of and cherished.  A June who did everything right, wore the right clothes, had the right style, had the perfect family.  
The Unveiling
      So, how in the world did I ever come to the conclusion that my mother suffers so?  She certainly didn't receive an official diagnosis.  She has received psychiatric care in the past, but rarely by her own consent. And that was due to "depression."  She talks to a counselor now, but only because my brothers and I have established a no-gossip boundary with her. She would call one of us, and complain about the "ill-treatment" she received from the others.  We finally decided we didn't need that.  She: "Well I have to talk to SOMEONE about how I am feeling!" Me: "Yes, so you will need to find a counselor.  It's not fair to me or my brothers for you to put us in the place of having to judge between you and each other."  So, amazingly she did find a counselor; however, when I asked her how it was going, she (speaking like a true narcissist), "It's going fine, but I think I'm giving her more counsel than she's giving me."  Oh well.  Anyway, a few months ago, she had an issue with my niece, J., an adult granddaughter who spends a great deal of time helping her.  My mother became very angry (in a rage, actually) with her and said some very hurtful things to her.  As she realized that she may have cut that relationship off, she did become remorseful.  I offered to help her meet with J. so she could offer an apology, seek forgiveness and re-establish the relationship.  When we met, J. tried to relate how sad she felt that her grandma would say such hurtful things to her.  Well, my mother did apologize. It went this way:  "I apologize that you heard me wrong. When I said that I didn't mean that, I meant this."  We could not get her to feel any sort of empathy for the hurt that her words had caused. Oh well.


          It had been awhile since she had a rage episode.  As long as I can remember, she had them every so often. Usually someone did or said something that would provoke her anger with which she would lash out with spiteful, hurtful words.  There was even one time she boxed my ears, and a few times I remember that she threw something at my dad.  The energy of the rage would ebb and a disabling depression would wash in and could swallow her for months. There were a few times that these cycles landed her in the psychiatric unit of the hospital.  It was after one of these rages, at my brother’s house, that she was finally diagnosed with “chronic depression.”  This was the first time she was appropriately medicated (previously she had been given sedatives or tranquilizers) with anti-depressant medication.   She enjoyed almost 10 years of relative peace. Last summer I started noticing some anxiety issues, and then in the fall, it seemed she was once again becoming depressed.  We all started noticing that she was not processing new information well. She has a great memory—no question about that, but learning new things from medication routines to using a new telephone is just not sinking in anymore.  Her doctor has adjusted her medication, and there is some improvement, but I think that age-related cognitive impairment is causing her to lose her emotional self-restraint.  Once again, I was face to face with the problems that had plagued our relationship in the past.  I could understand the depression, but what was the rage all about?  Was she bipolar and the rage her “manic” cycle?  I started Googling “depression + rage” and found and interesting quote somewhere: “Depression is anger turned inward.”   The article in which I found that quote also said that expressing rage and anger acted as a vent for the person, they are “blowing off steam,” and once the pressure of the anger was projected on to someone else, then the person would feel a measure of relief.  Well, it never seemed that giving vent to her anger helped my mom in any way—she was more depressed afterward.  Finally I found the article I linked in my previous post. It was if I found gold. I’ve since done more reading about NPD, and it all confirms the evidence of my mother’s narcissistic traits and the consequences of that behavior.  Finally, I feel I have an explanation.  Finally, I can figure out how to cope, how to heal, how to end the generational harm.  

Introductions
        Ha, I'm feeling kind of guilty just starting this blog.  Should I ask my mother for permission?  If she knew I was writing a blog about our relationship, our family, she would want full editorial privileges!   I am not going to tell her.  Maybe someday, but for now, I'm too chicken.  Yep, I'm 52 years old, she's 91, and I'm still afraid of facing her wrath. I do not intend on maligning my mother, or blaming her for the consequences of her behavior in my own life and the in the life of my family.  I've learned enough about narcissistic personality disorder to know that she thinks and behaves the way she does because of some childhood trauma has shaken to her to her core--something that she has never been able to process or heal.  I know she's mentally ill, and I know that someday she will find wholeness in Heaven.  I know that someday when I meet my Lord Jesus, my real and happy mother will be there at His side.  I have decided to write this blog to put my thoughts and feelings in order. I have only recently realized that my mother's problems, and consequently the problems in our relationship, is due to her narcissistic traits.  Even from the time I was a little girl, I felt intimidated by my mother. I knew there was something lacking, a closeness that should have been there but wasn't.  I remember trying to figure it out from even from my early teen years.  My 12 year old best friend once told me, "Your mother is crazy," and later my high school boyfriend said, "Your mom is insane." I figured they were just overstating things--everyone's mom gets a little crazy now and then, right? Thinking back, they must have seen something amiss. Now I'm wondering what other people may have seen, but just didn't say anything. Or, were appearances so well maintained that we looked like the perfect, all-American family? Don't get me wrong, on the whole, we lived a good life. My dad was loving and kind, and provided whatever genuine love that was lacking from Mom. He also provided, by his job as a professional flight engineer, a comfortable standard of living. Our parents gave my brothers and me lots of great experiences and opportunities. We went to church, and the people there were pretty much at the center of our family's social life. From the outside, I'm sure that everything looked great. But inside. Oh, inside we walked on eggshells. I feel guilty for "complaining" because we did enjoy so much, and after all, we didn't suffer physical abuse (well, maybe only a very few times), and our parents weren't getting drunk, or neglecting us. There's just this undercurrent of knowledge that something isn't right. My relationship with my mother doesn't feel right, and I always wondered why.

About Narcissistic Personality Disorder
     Here is a link to a terrific article on NPD:    How to Recognize a Narcissist  This link will get you to the introduction of the lengthy article.  At the bottom of the page, in the pink box, click on the subheadings to read the other parts of the article. Basically, a person develops narcissistic traits to cope with abuse or trauma in their early childhood.  Because the person's self-image is so demeaned or destroyed, they invent a new one.  The rest of their life is spent trying to live up to the false image they have created for themselves.  NPD is a "spectrum disorder" which means that people will exhibit varying degrees of narcissistic behaviors. More than half the traits describe my mother to one degree or another.